Exploring the Differences Between Standing Seam Metal vs Shingle Roofing

Explore the pros and cons of standing seam metal versus shingle roofing to determine the best choice for your home with Always Forward Roofing.

When choosing a roof for your home, the options can be overwhelming. Two leading contenders are Standing Seam Metal vs Shingle Roofing Choices. Each roofing material has its strengths, making it vital for homeowners to understand their differences. This knowledge can lead to better decisions that align with your budget, style, and functional needs.

Durability of Standing Seam Metal vs Shingle Roofs

Durability is a major factor when comparing metal roofs and asphalt shingles. AFR’s standard standing seam metal roofs are designed to last 50+ years, while copper roofing can endure up to 100 years with proper care. Metal is also fire-resistant and impervious to rot and insect damage.

On the other hand, shingle roofing has a shorter lifespan, lasting about 20 to 30 years. Shingles can withstand various weather conditions but are more likely to be damaged by hail or extreme weather.

Cost

Cost is a decisive factor for many homeowners. Shingle roofing has a lower upfront installation cost. For a standard 2,000-square-foot roof, homeowners might expect to pay around $10,000 for shingles.

In contrast, AFR’s standing seam metal roofing usually costs 2 to 2.5 times the price of a shingle roof. While this higher cost may seem daunting—around $25,000 for the same 2,000-square-foot roof—it’s essential to consider that longevity and less frequent repairs can offset the expense over time. Studies show that homeowners can save up to 25% on energy bills with metal roofs, which can contribute to overall savings.

Maintenance

In terms of maintenance, standing seam metal roofs excel. After installation, they generally require minimal attention periodic inspections and occasional cleaning are usually sufficient. Metal has the added advantage of resisting moss and algae growth.

In contrast, shingle roofs need more regular maintenance. Homeowners must check for missing or damaged shingles and periodically clean away debris to ensure longevity.

Energy Efficiency 

Energy efficiency is becoming increasingly important as homeowners look to reduce their environmental footprint. Metal roofs reflect solar heat, helping to keep homes cooler during the summer months. Research indicates that metal roofing can reduce energy consumption by up to 25% in warmer regions.

Conversely, traditional shingles absorb heat. While some newer shingles are designed with reflective materials, these improved energy-efficient shingle lines come with a higher price tag and still don’t quite match the energy efficiency of metal roofs.

Aesthetics 

Aesthetics play a significant role in roofing choices. Standing seam metal roofing comes in a wide variety of colors and finishes, allowing you to achieve a customized look. For example, modern metal roofs can mimic traditional materials like slate or wood shake without the added weight and maintenance.

Shingle roofing also offers a variety of colors and styles but does not have as many options for color choices. Those aiming for a distinct architectural style may prefer the tailored look that metal roofing affords.

Weather Resistance

Metal roofs excel in weather resistance and are designed to withstand extreme conditions such as strong winds and heavy rain. While both standing seam metal and shingle roofing can be damaged by hail, hail is much more detrimental to shingle roofs over time. Once the protective layer of a shingle roof is compromised, UV rays and weather can reach the fiberglass matting underneath, leading to faster deterioration and potential leaks. In contrast, metal roofing does not have this vulnerability, and even with dents from hail, it will not result in long-term leaks or accelerated breakdown, providing more reliable protection in hail-prone areas.

While shingle roofs are reasonably sturdy, they can suffer damage from high winds or heavy rain. For instance, 3-tab shingles can lift and tear off in winds exceeding 60 mph. Architectural shingles, on the other hand, perform similarly to standing seam metal roofing and are rated for winds of 110–130 mph with proper installation.

Installation Process 

The installation of metal roofs can be more complex due to the weight and unique properties of the material. While skilled installation is essential for both types of roofing materials, shingle roofing is usually easier to install, requiring less time and, therefore, lower labor costs.

Ultimately, the effectiveness and longevity of both roofs hinge on proper installation. Hiring qualified contractors can ensure that your roofing system performs well over its intended lifespan.

Environmental Impact 

As sustainability grows in importance, the environmental impact of roofing materials cannot be overlooked. Metal roofing is often made from recycled materials and is fully recyclable at the end of its life, making it a more eco-friendly option.

In contrast, shingles generally end up in landfills. With an average lifespan of just 20 to 30 years, this contributes significant waste. Homeowners seeking greener materials may find metal roofing a better fit for their values.

Final Thoughts 

Each roofing option presents unique benefits and challenges. Your decision will depend on various factors, including budget, climate, and personal style. Standing Seam Metal roofs offer remarkable durability, energy savings, and low maintenance, appealing to those who are prepared to invest more upfront. Meanwhile, shingle roofing can provide an affordable initial investment while still delivering style and reliability.

Before making a final choice, consulting with our residential roofing experts can help determine what suits your specific needs best. By weighing the discussed factors in this standing seam metal vs shingle comparison, you can make a well-informed decision that will enhance your home for years to come.

If you have any questions or want to explore your roofing options further, contact us today!

Example of our Standing Seam Metal Roofing

Aerial view of a charming brick house with a modern metal roof, a spacious wooden deck with seating and a barbecue, surrounded by lush greenery.

Example of our Shingle Roofing

Aerial view of a house with a well-maintained asphalt shingle roof, surrounded by a green lawn and small garden.

Visit our Shingle Gallery for more of this: https://www.alwaysforwardroofing.com/shingle-color-gallery